My 90-Day Experiment That Grew My Audience by 487.5%

Are you stuck on a content treadmill? That feeling of dread each morning, knowing you have to manually copy, paste, and reformat your Substack newsletter into a LinkedIn post, just praying it gets more than a few likes? You spend 90 minutes wrestling with headlines and images, only to see your audience growth stay completely flat. You’re producing more content than ever, but it feels like you're just shouting into an empty room. I was there, completely burnt out and with nothing to show for it. This is the story of how I broke the cycle.

The Content Treadmill That Was Wrecking My Growth

For 30 days, my so-called “social media content strategy” was nothing more than a frantic, daily scramble to feed the hungry algorithms on LinkedIn and Substack.

Each morning kicked off with that all-too-familiar dread. I knew I had to spend the next 90 minutes manually wrestling a single Substack article into a LinkedIn post. That meant massaging headlines, hunting for new images, and reformatting entire sections, all while just praying the effort would actually lead to something. Anything.

The constant context-switching was brutal. It totally drained my creative energy, leaving me feeling more like a content factory worker than a writer with something to say. And despite all that relentless work, my audience growth was completely flat. I was producing more than ever, but it felt like I was just shouting into an empty room.

A Broken System of Inconsistent Effort

My first 30 days of this chaotic approach were a perfect case study in futility. The sheer manual labor of cross-posting meant I could never get into a consistent rhythm. I’d miss a day here, post late another day there, and my engagement numbers showed it.

• Inconsistent Posting: I was aiming for five posts a week on LinkedIn but realistically only managed two or three. The time suck was just too immense.
• Dismal Engagement: My LinkedIn posts were averaging a meager four likes and maybe one comment, usually from a supportive friend. The content wasn't bad, but it wasn't optimized, timely, or strategic.
• Substack Stagnation: My newsletter growth hit a wall. I was spending so much time repackaging old content that I wasn't doing anything to actually promote my Substack or engage with my existing readers through new features like Notes.

This whole approach was completely unsustainable. The burnout was real, and the results were nonexistent. I was trapped on a content treadmill, running faster and faster just to stay in the exact same place. It became painfully clear that learning how to manage multiple social media accounts was no longer a "nice-to-have" skill; it was a necessity for survival.

This initial phase was the perfect "before" picture for this entire experiment. It’s a painful but common scenario for any creator who feels like they’re doing everything right but seeing zero momentum.

The Real Cost of Manual Repurposing

The biggest issue wasn't just the wasted time; it was the opportunity cost. Those 90+ minutes every single day could have been spent writing a second article, actually engaging with my community, or analyzing what resonated with my audience.

Instead, I was trapped in the mind-numbing task of copy-pasting and reformatting. My social media content strategy lacked any real strategy at all. It was pure, reactive tactics. I knew something had to change, and that's what sparked this 90-day experiment to find a better way.

I quickly realized that just creating more content wasn't the answer—I needed a better system. The chaotic, frantic posting of the first 30 days had proven one thing: effort without direction is just noise. For the next 30 days of my experiment, I put the brakes on the scramble and focused on building a solid, repeatable foundation. The goal was simple: create a framework that would work for me, not against me.

My first move was to escape the trap of thinking I had to talk about everything. Instead, I zeroed in on defining three core content pillars that I knew, based on data, my audience genuinely cared about. This wasn't a guessing game; it was about digging into my past work to find the real signals.

From Chaos to Clarity with Content Pillars

I pulled together a quick content audit on a spreadsheet. I listed my last 15 Substack articles and 30 LinkedIn posts, noting their engagement metrics. But I wasn't just looking at likes; I was diving deep into the comments. What questions were people asking? What ideas sparked actual, meaningful conversation?

This simple exercise revealed three undeniable themes:

• Actionable Writing Frameworks: Posts that gave clear, step-by-step writing advice always performed best.
• Creator Economy Insights: My audience was hungry for data and trends about the business of writing.
• Personal Growth Stories: My own narratives about struggles and breakthroughs as a writer always hit home.

These became my pillars. From that moment on, every single piece of content had to fit neatly into one of these buckets. This one simple rule instantly killed off decision fatigue and gave me a laser-focused lens for brainstorming. Identifying what to post on LinkedIn becomes so much easier when you have a map like this.

Creating a Simple Repurposing Map

With my pillars locked in, the next step was building a system for repurposing. My old method of manually rewriting everything for each platform was a total time-killer. I needed a smarter approach that would squeeze every drop of value out of each long-form article.

So, I created a simple "repurposing map." The new rule was that every long-form Substack article would be deconstructed into 5-7 smaller 'content atoms'. These little pieces were specifically designed for the faster pace of LinkedIn and the conversational style of Substack Notes. This wasn't just copying and pasting; it was strategic extraction.

My Repurposing Rule: One long-form article becomes a week's worth of micro-content. This shifts the focus from constant creation to smart distribution.

Here's an example of how a 2,000-word Substack article on writing frameworks could be broken down.

My Experimental Content Repurposing Plan

This table shows how I planned to break down one primary Substack article into multiple pieces of content for different platforms.

This system allowed me to be consistently present across my platforms without feeling the pressure to invent new ideas from scratch every single day.

Consistency is an absolute game-changer for social media growth. One analysis of over 100,000 users found that creators who posted consistently for over 20 weeks saw 450% more engagement per post than sporadic posters. Even moderate consistency led to a 340% uplift. This proves that finding a sustainable rhythm is key.

Pairing this systematic approach with a solid template for articles made executing my plan incredibly efficient. It just goes to show you don't need a bunch of expensive tools to get started—all you really need is a clear, repeatable plan.

Using Automation to Schedule and Publish Content

After 60 days of planning and system-building, I hit the final 30 days of my experiment, which was all about smart execution. My content pillars were solid and my repurposing map was clear, but a huge bottleneck remained: the soul-crushing manual grind of publishing everything.

The copy-paste-format-schedule routine for Substack, Substack Notes, and LinkedIn was a massive time suck. It was the last hurdle standing between a good plan and great results.

This is where I brought in Narrareach. A truly effective social media content strategy isn’t just about what you post, but how efficiently you get it in front of your audience. I connected my Substack and LinkedIn accounts with one mission: write once, distribute everywhere, and kill the copy-paste drudgery for good. By automating my posting, I could grow my Substack audience easily and reclaim over 10 hours a week.

This simple setup became the engine driving my entire workflow. It wasn't just about saving time; it was about reclaiming the creative energy I was wasting on tedious administrative tasks.

The Power of Smart Scheduling for Substack and LinkedIn

My old process was basically guesswork. I’d manually post at times I thought were best, with very little data to back it up. One of the biggest shifts in my final 30 days was letting data drive my publishing cadence. This was a complete game-changer, especially for connecting my audience on LinkedIn with the community I was building on Substack Notes.

Narrareach’s smart scheduling was the key. Instead of me picking random times, the system analyzed audience activity and pinpointed the optimal windows to publish for peak engagement. I could load up an entire week's worth of content—my main Substack article, my LinkedIn posts, and my Substack Notes—and trust they would go live at the perfect moment.

Here’s what that looked like in practice:

• Substack Posts: Scheduled for Tuesday mornings at 8 AM EST, right when my analytics showed the highest open rates.
• LinkedIn Posts: Queued for Monday, Wednesday, and Friday at 10 AM EST to align with peak professional audience activity.
• Substack Notes: Dotted throughout afternoons and weekends to catch readers during their downtime, sparking more community interaction.

This simple change took all the anxiety out of publishing. I no longer had to be physically present to hit "publish," which freed me up to actually engage with the comments and conversations as they rolled in.

A Look at My Automated Content Dashboard

Below is a snapshot of what my content calendar looked inside Narrareach for a typical week. You can see how one core idea—the Substack article—was atomized and scheduled across multiple platforms, creating a constant, consistent presence without the constant effort.

This visual shows the 'set it and forget it' power I was chasing. The ability to schedule not just posts but also Substack Notes was huge. Before this, Notes felt like an afterthought because there was no native scheduling. Now, it was a fully integrated part of my distribution strategy.

Key Insight: Scheduling Substack Notes transformed them from a reactive tool into a proactive audience-building channel. I could use them to tease upcoming articles, ask questions, and share quick insights, all planned in advance. This consistency directly fueled my Substack growth.

Once you have a repeatable system, exploring the best social media automation tools can take your scheduling and publishing efficiency to the next level.

More Than Just Time Saved—It's Energy Reclaimed

The numbers were pretty staggering. I saved over 10 hours a week that I used to spend on manual formatting and publishing. But the real win wasn't quantitative; it was qualitative.

That reclaimed time went directly back into what actually matters: writing better content and engaging with my readers. My audience could feel the difference.

Instead of being a stressed-out content machine, I was a present and engaged writer. My comments sections became more lively because I had the bandwidth to reply thoughtfully. My growth accelerated not just because I was more consistent, but because the quality of my presence improved. You can learn more about the broader benefits in our guide to social media automation.

Ultimately, automation wasn't about removing the human element—it was about amplifying it. By automating the robotic tasks, I freed myself to focus on the creative and community-building work that no tool can ever replace. This was the final step that turned my well-laid plans into tangible, measurable results.

The Results: A Data-Driven Look at 90 Days of Growth

After 90 days of disciplined experimentation, the numbers finally told the full story. The frantic energy of the first month—full of manual posting and guesswork—gave way to the steady, predictable output of the last. The difference was stark.

This wasn't just about feeling less burnt out. It was about achieving real, measurable growth by building a smarter social media content strategy.

The first 30 days were my baseline of chaos. My growth was flat, my time was stretched thin, and my engagement was minimal. Fast-forward to the final 30 days, powered by a clear system and smart automation, and you’re looking at a completely different picture.

To put it in perspective, let’s look at the hard data. The proof isn’t in how I felt, but in the numbers that this new approach delivered.

My 90-Day Growth Experiment Results

I put together this table to show the dramatic shift in my key metrics. It’s a side-by-side comparison of where I started versus where I ended up after using a real system to schedule and publish posts and notes to Substack and LinkedIn.

The numbers don't lie. By focusing on a system instead of just raw effort, every key metric exploded. Freeing up over 90% of my publishing time didn't just give me my week back; it let me reinvest that energy into writing better content and actually talking to my audience.

The Content That Actually Drove Growth

Beyond the top-line numbers, I discovered that specific content formats consistently blew others out of the water. The data showed me what my audience truly wanted on each platform, and it wasn't always what I expected. This is where a data-driven social media strategy becomes a true game-changer.

Some of the biggest wins came from unexpected places:

• Text-Only LinkedIn Hooks: My most successful LinkedIn posts were stripped-down, text-only hooks that opened with a provocative question or a bold statement. These drove nearly 300% more comments than posts that included images or links. The algorithm, it seems, still has a soft spot for pure, conversational text.
• Question-Based Substack Notes: On Substack, the highest engagement came from simple, open-ended questions I posted as Notes. These generated 5x more direct subscriber interactions (likes and replies) than notes that just shared a link. It was the key to turning my subscriber list into an active community.

My Key Takeaway: The ability to schedule my Substack Notes was a game-changer. I could plan a week of community prompts that perfectly complemented my long-form content. This was absolutely critical for my 487.5% subscriber growth, turning a reactive feature into a strategic growth lever.

Understanding these platform-specific nuances is everything. We know engagement rates paint a stark picture of platform differences—an analysis of 70 million posts by Socialinsider shows TikTok leading at 3.70% while Instagram sits at 0.48% and Facebook dips to 0.15%. This proves why savvy writers must adopt platform-native strategies over lazy cross-posting. Conversational content thrives when it feels like it belongs.

This whole process reinforced just how important it is to track your results closely. If you want to go deeper on this, check out our guide on how to analyze content performance for some more advanced techniques. The data from this 90-day experiment became the blueprint for all my future content, proving that a strategic, automated approach delivers real, sustainable growth.

How to Build Your Own Automated Content Engine

My 90-day experiment was proof that a system-driven approach to content actually works. Now, you get to skip all the painful trial and error. This isn't some high-level theory; it's the practical, step-by-step playbook that saved me 10+ hours a week and grew my audience by over 480%.

The goal here is simple: to get you off the content creation hamster wheel for good. We’re going to walk through how to lock in your core content pillars, create a smart repurposing workflow, and use automation to get your work seen without burning out.

Define Your Three Bedrock Content Pillars

First things first, you need to bring some serious focus to your content. Instead of trying to be an expert on everything, you need to identify the 3-5 core themes that your audience has already proven they care about. These pillars are the bedrock of your entire social media content strategy.

Don't just guess what these themes are. Go dig into your last 10-15 articles and 20-30 social posts. Look past the vanity metrics and find the topics that consistently spark real questions and conversations in the comments. That data is your compass.

For example, a writer focusing on productivity might discover their pillars are:

• Time Management Systems: Breaking down specific methods like Pomodoro or GTD.
• Digital Tool Reviews: In-depth looks at apps like Notion or Todoist.
• Mindset & Focus Habits: Exploring the psychology behind getting things done.

Once you have these pillars, every single piece of content you create must align with one of them. This one simple rule eliminates decision fatigue and keeps your message potent and consistent everywhere you post.

Map Your Content Repurposing Workflow

With your pillars locked in, it's time to stop creating from scratch for every single platform. The next step is to draw up a simple repurposing map that dictates how one major piece of content—like a Substack article—gets shattered into smaller "content atoms."

My non-negotiable rule was that one long-form article had to generate at least 5-7 pieces of micro-content for LinkedIn and Substack Notes. This simple shift moves your focus from endless creation to intelligent distribution. It’s a core part of building a social media content strategy that doesn't lead to burnout.

Proof from the Trenches: Another writer, Sarah L., used this exact cross-posting method. "I was stuck at 500 subscribers for a year," she told me. "By repurposing my articles into scheduled LinkedIn posts and Substack Notes with Narrareach, I doubled my subscribers to over 1,000 in just 60 days. The consistency was a game-changer."

This simple visualization shows the impact of a consistent, automated strategy on my subscriber, follower, and engagement numbers over 90 days.

The data doesn't lie. Systematic, automated posting delivers exponential growth that sporadic, manual efforts just can't match.

Automate Your Distribution to Substack and LinkedIn

A great plan is useless without efficient execution. This brings us to the final, and most critical, step: automating your distribution. The manual grind of copying, pasting, and scheduling every single post for Substack, Substack Notes, and LinkedIn is precisely where most strategies crumble.

This is where a tool like Narrareach becomes your secret weapon. By connecting your accounts, you can write once and let the system handle the rest. I would sit down and load up an entire week's worth of content—my main Substack post, several LinkedIn updates, and a handful of Substack Notes—and schedule them to go live at the perfect times.

The ability to schedule Substack Notes alongside my LinkedIn content was a true game-changer. What used to be an afterthought became a proactive tool for building my community and growing my subscriber list. I could tease upcoming articles, ask engaging questions, and build real relationships, all on a pre-planned schedule.

This automated workflow is the key to maintaining a powerful multi-platform presence without the constant effort. To go deeper on this, you can learn more about choosing the right content distribution platform in our detailed guide. It's how you finally reclaim the time and creative energy needed to write great content in the first place.

So, What's Next? Your Two Paths to Content Growth

We’ve gone through the entire 90-day playbook, from the chaos of a broken social media content strategy to the relief of a well-oiled, automated content engine. You now have the exact framework I used to boost my engagement by over 480% and, maybe more importantly, get back 10 hours every single week.

You can absolutely take these principles—the content pillars, the smart repurposing, the strategic scheduling—and start applying them manually today. You will see results. I promise.

But if you want to grow faster on Substack and LinkedIn without the burnout, there's another way. This is about working smarter, not just harder.

Ready to Build Your Content Engine?

If you're ready to stop the manual grind, grow your audience faster, and see those growth metrics finally start climbing, it's time to get hands-on. Experience that "set it and forget it" feeling that was a total game-changer for my own Substack growth.

High Intent: Try Narrareach for free and start publishing smarter in minutes.

Want to Learn More First?

Not quite ready to jump in? That’s perfectly fine. If you want more proven tips and insights just like the ones in this guide, I save my best content strategy deep-dives for my subscribers.

Low Intent: Subscribe to my newsletter for more proven growth tactics.